• Funnel Vision
  • Posts
  • Did AI Just Change Ad Creative Forever? Yes... and No.

Did AI Just Change Ad Creative Forever? Yes... and No.

OpenAI’s latest drop has marketers freaking out. But there’s more to the story. Here’s what GPT-4o Image Generation really changes for performance marketers—and what's staying exactly the same.

Welcome back to Funnel Vision, the weekly newsletter that puts performance creative & growth marketing in focus. Brought to you by the crew at Ready Set.

The greatest April Fool’s prank could be that no one actually knows how the tradition started. Maybe it was a calendar mix-up. Maybe it was Romans in wigs. Either way, the tradition of laughing at confusion has some seriously confusing origins.

Here’s what’s inside today’s edition:

  • What OpenAI’s viral drop really means for performance marketers

  • How this ad combined testing + social proof for a 40% thumbstop

  • The latest industry news you may have missed

Reading time: 5 minutes

AI Images Just Got Scary Good. Here’s What It Means for Performance Creative.

Here's what GPT-4o Image Generation really changes for performance marketers—and what's staying exactly the same.

Marketers and AI enthusiasts everywhere are (again) breathlessly declaring, “This changes everything.”

To say OpenAI’s latest image generation tool made waves is like saying Argentinians are mildly fond of Messi—a massive understatement.

AI-generated creations are already flooding feeds. And they’re… pretty good!

But with these impressive visuals comes the inevitable chatter—graphic designers are doomed, the future of ad creative has arrived, and everything in between.

All this hype prompts the question: Is this truly a tipping point for performance marketing? Or just another shiny object?

Let’s unpack it.

🧠 What Just Dropped

Last week, OpenAI introduced 4o Image Generation—a native, built-in image generator that replaces DALL·E as the new default. 

💡 That “native” part is important: Images are generated directly inside the familiar chat interface, making it faster and more intuitive to build upon and refine images while maintaining consistency.

Predictably, the internet exploded with excitement over the new tool.

Social feeds flooded with Studio Ghibli-style renderings of memes and movie scenes, recreations of iconic ads featuring different products, and countless frighteningly photorealistic images.

It went so viral that OpenAI had to pause free access—Sam Altman said it was “melting GPUs.”

Naturally, we couldn't resist jumping in ourselves.

I’m re-watching Game of Thrones. (Don’t ask me why. Yes I know about season eight.) The medieval era is on my mind. So, I gave it a shot…

Here’s the prompt: Create an image of a fully-armored Destrier war horse with a medieval knight mounted on its back after a battle.

How cool is that?!

💥 Why Performance Marketers Need to Pay Attention

Until recently, AI image generation was mostly a novelty. Cool for mood boards and brainstorming, but hardly ready for prime time. 

Plus, the best tools were niche, tricky, or expensive. (Anyone else bail on Midjourney? Just me?)

But that's all changed.

With 4o, anyone can produce scroll-stopping visuals in minutes, directly in the chat interface we're all familiar with. For free.

We're talking images that rival professional photographers and illustrators.

Unlike previous tools, 4o even tackles tricky details—like rendering readable text. Sure, it's not perfect yet, but it’s come a long way from those weird AI squiggles.

Here’s our medieval fella from before, writing a recount of the battle…

Pretty solid for medieval handwriting! And check out those hands—AI hands have officially leveled up.

Back to what this means…

The cost and speed of producing ad creative have dropped dramatically. What used to take a designer hours now takes a non-creative marketer minutes with a simple prompt.

Major caveat:

Despite this mind-bending quantum leap forward, there’s still one fundamental element—maybe the fundamental element—to running effective campaigns that still hasn’t been overtaken by AI, and perhaps never will.

To unpack that, we asked Susan, our VP of Client Strategy, to weigh in.

TL;DR: Don’t Confuse Speed with Strategy

Artificial intelligence is democratizing content creation before our eyes. But let’s not get it twisted. AI is a tool; not a replacement for strategic creative thinking.

Just because you can generate dozens of ads in minutes doesn’t mean they’ll perform. The difference is always whether the strategy driving the ad encapsulates:

  • Why people buy (the psychology)

  • How audiences behave on different platforms

Brands winning right now use AI to accelerate these strategic fundamentals:

1️⃣ Lead with audience insights, not product features.

Great creative solves real problems or taps into customer aspirations. Deep insights drive results, and AI helps uncover these faster.

2️⃣ Test with discipline and clear hypotheses.

AI accelerates testing—great news. But speed without structure creates chaos. Stick to testing fundamentals: isolate one variable at a time, document clear hypotheses, track performance rigorously, and double down only on proven creative.

3️⃣ Optimize for each platform’s nuances.

Ads that crush on TikTok can flop on Instagram. Tailor creative to the platform’s context and audience mindset. Never assume what works in one place automatically transfers.

Look, I use ChatGPT to spin up ideas all the time. It’s incredible for jump-starting the creative process. But treat it like a first draft, not a final product. Use it to brief a designer, or test a wild-card idea quickly. Then I refine based on data.

Bottom line: AI is an incredible tool, but it’s not a substitute for strategy, insight, or creative judgment.

Your audience is telling you what they need and when they’re ready to buy. The data is there—you just have to listen and act on it.

🚀 Where We Go From Here

AI just raised the speed limit—but performance still comes down to having the best strategy.

At Ready Set, we blend tailored creative strategies with deft tactical execution. Our team of performance creative experts know exactly what makes your audience stop, click, and buy—and we leverage the latest tools (yep, including AI) to move faster without sacrificing effectiveness.

Ready to unlock creative mastery through sharper strategies and technical precision?

Refer Ready Set to marketers in your network and get $1,000 if they become a client.

🍎 French antitrust regulator have slapped Apple with a €150 million ($162 million) fine over their App Tracking Transparency (ATT) tool but reportedly refrained from asking “How do you like them apples?” as they did so.

🤷‍♀️ Amazon is reportedly the latest to make a last-ditch bid to buy TikTok with the ban set to take effect (again) over the weekend.

🤑 How Meta makes its money (hint: it’s ads).

👾 Why advertisers haven’t embraced gaming, despite it being $11.5B market by 2028.

😒 Tariffs set to be bad news for anyone relying on ad revenue, according to this analysis.

🤡 Fried chicken-flavored toothpaste. No more peach iced tea. Pickle milk (ew). These are the best and weirdest April Fool’s pranks from food brands.

AD OF THE WEEK ✨

This week’s ad from meal delivery brand Wild Alaskan Company leans into the power of social proof to simultaneously hook attention and build trust.

Social proof and mouthwatering visuals are the starts of this ad from Wild Alaskan Company.

Brand: Wild Alaskan Company
Length: 40 seconds
Platform: Facebook & Instagram

WHY IT WORKS 🧠

🧪 Rigorous testing identified the winning hook. By launching four variations with different openers simultaneously, we quickly surfaced the messaging that resonated most. This methodical testing led to a standout 40.6% thumbstop rate.

🤔 It respectfully challenges the viewer. The ad earns trust with real praise, then flips the script: Why settle for less? This unexpected question, paired with mouthwatering visuals and raw, natural scenes, creates a moment of reflection that compels viewers to reconsider their choices.

🗣️ Social proof is the star of the show. Instead of reinventing the wheel, we leaned into what real customers were already saying. By pulling 5-star reviews into the spotlight, the ad feels authentic and trustworthy—tapping into relatable voices to drive signups.

Thanks for reading!

That’s all for this week. Seeya next time 🫶 

What do you think of Funnel Vision?

Login or Subscribe to participate in polls.

Dan Moran & Sam Makalou

Psst... wanna earn $1k?

Know someone looking for efficiency, flexibility, and scale with performance creative and media buying? Refer brands in your network and earn $1,000.