• Funnel Vision
  • Posts
  • Video Ads Tanking? Hereā€™s Whyā€”and How To Fix It

Video Ads Tanking? Hereā€™s Whyā€”and How To Fix It

Your guide to navigating 4 all-too-common (and very fixable) performance scenarios. Plus: Analyzing a trend-setting TikTok ad šŸ”„

Welcome back to the latest issue of Funnel Vision, the weekly newsletter that puts performance creative & growth marketing in focus. Brought to you by the crew at Ready Set.

Ever launch a video ad that seemed perfect... only to watch it underperform?

Even worse, you donā€™t know why itā€™s tanking?

Optimizing ads based on performance data might seem like reading tea leaves at first. But once you know what patterns to look for, it becomes surprisingly straightforwardā€”and these four scenarios come up more than you may thinkā€¦

Reading time: 5 minutes.

How to optimize your video ads (based on data)

You've done everything right. Nailed the creative concept. Perfected the production. Fine-tuned every frame in editing.

Finally, your video ad is live.

While it can feel like crossing the finish line, the real work has only just begun.

What you do after the concept is live can make the difference between an okay ad and a top-performer.

Analyzing performance metrics can be intimidating. Actioning them? Even more so. But once you realize certain patterns tend to emerge more than others, optimization becomes less about guesswork and more about strategy.

Let's break down the four most common scenarios we seeā€”and exactly what to do when you encounter them.

High Thumbstop, Low Conversion Rate (CVR)

An image of a graph showing metrics of an ad with a high thumbstop rate and a low CVR.

This ad is catching your audienceā€™s attention, but failing to convert them.

The opening seconds of the ad are doing a good job, but performance is being dragged down by the rest of the content. The likely culprits?

  • Misaligned messaging that doesnā€™t clearly communicate value propositionsā€”both in the ad and on the destination landing page.

  • A weak call to action (CTA) that fails to compel or is introduced too late

How to fix it

šŸŖŸ Clarify the value and benefits of your product/service with tighter and more compelling messaging. Create a consistent and cohesive flow throughout the ad and the landing page.

šŸ’Ŗ Strengthen the CTA, or introduce it earlier. Be direct in what you want someone to do next and provide a clear path to do it.

Low Thumbstop, High CVR

An image of a graph showing metrics of an ad with a low thumbstop rate and a high CVR.

This ad isnā€™t doing a great job at stopping the scroll. But users that do click are converting at a higher rate.

Capitalize on that strong conversion rate by increasing the number of people who make it to the landing page. In this scenario, thereā€™s just one course of action to do thatā€¦

Strengthen that intro.

How to fix it

šŸ‹ļø Test different openers. Vary the visuals, super, and sound to see what shifts the thumbstop.

šŸŽ£ Add a compelling hook designed to grab and hold attention.

šŸ‘„ Itā€™s critical the adā€™s format and style adhere with the norms and expectations of the platform on which itā€™s running.

High Click-Thru Rate (CTR), Low CVR

An image of a graph showing metrics of an ad with a high CTR and a low CVR.

Great! Your ad is getting clicks. Not so greatā€¦ those clicks arenā€™t turning into conversions.

Now, I know what youā€™re thinking. If people arenā€™t converting, the problem is with the landing page, right? Well, yesā€”but itā€™s only half the problem.

The fix comes from aligning the expectations set by the ad with the experience of the destination.

How to fix it

šŸ—Æļø Ensure coherent messaging throughout to ensure the destination deliverers on the promises made in the ad.

āž”ļø Simplify the conversion path. Evaluate the UX to reduce friction and the steps required to convert.

šŸš§ Make sure your conversion funnel is working and itā€™s not a tracking issue.

Low CTR, High CVR

An image of a graph showing metrics of an ad with a low CTR and a high CVR.

Similar to the low-thumbstop scenario above, the ad needs to be more enticing.

Itā€™s about making that CTA impossible to ignore.

How to fix it

šŸŽÆ Make the CTA more prominent and compelling to encourage clicks.

ā±ļø Deliver your key message earlier in the ad to catch interest quickly.

šŸ‘ļø Enhance the visual appeal and ensure the CTA stands out.

šŸ‘ Rule of Thumb

Hereā€™s a nifty principle to help guide your ad optimization:

ā†—ļø Metrics expressed as a rate or percentage need to be higher (e.g. Thumbstop, CTR, CVR, ROAS)

ā†˜ļø Metrics expressed as a cost need to be lower (e.g. CPM, CPA, CPC)

šŸ•µļø Choose your own adventure, privacy edition. For users in the EU, Meta has lowered the price of Subscription for no ads. Theyā€™re also offering free with ā€œless personalizedā€ ads or free with the usual "we know you better than you know yourself" experience.

šŸŽ¬ YouTube Shorts is getting new ad formats including interactive stickers and animated products (great for brands lacking video creative). It's like TikTok Shop and Instagram Shopping had a baby, but make it Google.

šŸŽ® 2024's most-used passwords include 'minecraft' and 'pokemon'. Your favorite game might spark joy, but it probably shouldn't guard your bank account.

Turn Compliance Constraints into Creative Rocket Fuel šŸš€

Most marketers in scrutinized industries default to safe, vanilla campaigns. The result? A sea of forgettable marketing that blends together like beige on beige.

But what if those regulatory constraints could become your secret weapon?

Join us for the next Screen Share session weā€™ll reveal how top brands turn compliance hurdles into creative advantages.

You'll discover:

  • Proven strategies for scaling user acquisition while navigating strict regulations

  • Full-funnel growth tactics that stay compliant without putting you to sleep

  • Frameworks for transforming "safe" creative into scroll-stopping content

šŸ—“ļø When: November 19th at 12PM CT
ā³ļø How long: One hour.

Whether you're drowning in red tape or hunting for your next big creative breakthrough, this session is packed with actionable strategies to help you stand outā€”and keep your legal team happy.

Limited spots available!

AD OF THE WEEK āœØ 

In this section, we analyze high-performing ads and extract actionable insights you can use to power your creative.

This Brigit ad masterfully transforms a common financial pain point into entertainment, generating massive engagement through relationship dynamics and clever misdirection.

A frame from a Brigit ad shows a young woman sitting cross-legged on a beige couch with a laptop. Text overlay reads "Asking my girlfriend for money to see her reaction" with a laughing emoji.

Brand: Brigit
Length: 25 seconds
Platform: TikTok

A guy asks his girlfriend for money and gets rejected. When he casually mentions getting money from "Brigit" instead, what begins as a potential relationship drama pivots into a clever product reveal, catching viewers off-guard and sparking intrigue about the financial app.

WHY IT WORKS šŸ§ 

šŸŽ­ The Jealousy Hook: Creates immediate emotional investment by playing into relationship insecurities. The girlfriend's suspicion of "Brigit" being another woman drives both narrative tension and organic shareability.

šŸŽÆ Problem-Solution Framing: Presents the product as the hero in a relatable financial scenario. The casual ask for money ā†’ rejection ā†’ solution path mirrors the exact customer journey Brigit wants to own.

šŸ˜‚ Meta-Humor: Breaking the fourth wall with "Are you filming a TikTok?" transforms potential skepticism into entertainment, making the ad feel self-aware rather than salesy.

STEAL THIS šŸ’”

1. Tap into trends. This ad didnā€™t just lean into a trend, it started one. The more you iterate, the more you increase your odds of landing a hit.

2. Use relationship dynamics to transform dry product features into emotional storytelling moments.

3. Donā€™t shy away from lo-fi production. If this ad looks like it was shot on a smartphone, itā€™s because it was. But itā€™s one of this clientā€™s best performing ads.

BOTTOM LINE šŸ‘‡

The most powerful ads don't sell productsā€”they sell relatable moments where your product just happens to be the perfect solution.

Thatā€™s a wrap!

Thatā€™s all for this installment of Funnel Vision. Thanks for reading!

Catch you next Friday šŸ«¶

Dan Moran

Content Marketing Manager

Psst... wanna earn $1k?

Know someone looking for efficiency, flexibility, and scale with performance creative and media buying? Refer brands in your network and earn $1,000.